North-Western Basin Branch News

The court of cassation instance cancelled the appeal court decision under the claim to OOO “Port Vyborg”

On March, 16th, 2010 Federal Arbitration Court of Northwest District considered the FSUE “Rosmorport” appeal on the decision of the Thirteenth Arbitration Appeal Court from 21.12.2009 for the case № A56-10973/2009, which cancelled the decision of Arbitration Court of St.-Petersburg and Leningrad Region under the claim of FSUE “Rosmorport” to OOO “Port Vyborg”.

The court of cassation instance recognized as correct the conclusion of court of the first instance about invalidity (negligibility) of the rent contract not coordinated with Federal Agency for State Property Management, and the obligation of OOO “Port Vyborg” to return superficially saved money which must be paid for using of the real estate objects to FSUE “Rosmorport”.

The appeal court decision was cancelled, the decision of Arbitration Court of St.-Petersburg and Leningrad Region from 14.09.2009 about clearing of moorings, collecting of superficial enrichment and percent for using another's money resources was upheld.